Our Menu
"Warning: Consuming raw or undercooked foods such as meat, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.
Taylors Tempters
Extra dressing +$0.99
Fire-Roasted Salsa $6.99 | White Creamy Queso Cheese $8.99 • Served with warm tortilla chips.
Breaded cauliflower with Aleppo pepper for a nice, spicy kick, fried and served with a side of ranch.
These lightly breaded cheese stix (6) are magnificent. Served piping hot with marinara.
(10) Pepper Jack mac & cheese filled bites. Macaroni mixed with creamy Pepper Jack cheese in a crispy garlic batter. Fried up nice and hot! Served with a side of ranch.
Fresh-cut skins (5) loaded with mozzarella, cheddar and bacon. Served with sour cream.
Fresh giant pretzel (salted or unsalted). Baked and served with spicy mustard • Add Queso or Pimento Cheese Dip +$3.49
A toasty French bread topped with cheddar and mozzarella cheese. Served with our house marinara.
½ lb. or 1 lb. of shrimp steamed to perfection in our seafood seasoning, fresh from Frosty's nets! Deveined and sliced for easy peel. Served with a side of cocktail sauce.
Three pairs of frog legs! Fried just like Uncle Rico likes them. Try them with butter garlic or our hot sauce.
Straight from Erie, PA. These wings are the plumpest around! Try them in BBQ, Mild, Teriyaki with Diced Pineapple, Butter Garlic Parmesan, Hot, Scorned Woman, Carolina Gold, Sweet Red Chili and Red Dragon (our house spiced-teriyaki) • 8 wings choice of 1 flavor only | 12 wings choice of 2 flavors +$7.00 • Extra wing sauce +$0.99 | Requesting all flats or all drums +$3.00
Pick your sauce: Hot, Mild, BBQ, Butter Garlic, Teriyaki, Red Dragon, Sweet Red Chili, Carolina Gold, Scorned Woman. 10 chicken bites with a choice of dressing.
Filled with pork and veggies. These little pockets of joy will have your mouth watering. Served with Frosty's version of General Tso's hot sweet sauce (6).
(5) Scallops wrapped with bacon, blackened and grilled on a skewer. Served on a bed of greens with a side of roasted red pepper sauce.
This is Frosty's best catch yet! Try our delicious take on a Tuna Poke appetizer. Sliced ahi tuna served over a bed of spinach and wasabi slaw and topped with sesame seeds. Served with General Tso's sauce.
(10) Shrimp breaded and fried. Served with a side of French fries • Tossed in Buffalo or boom boom sauce with a side of ranch or blue cheese +$1.99
Fried and lightly dusted rings and tentacles. Served with marinara sauce and lemon.
Harter's Salads
Dressings: Ranch, Blue Cheese, Honey Mustard, Caesar, Vidalia Onion, Fat-Free Italian, and Balsamic. Extra dressing +$0.99
Freshly chopped romaine and iceberg. Covered with mozzarella, cheddar, onions, diced tomato and a medley of croutons.
A blend of romaine and iceberg lettuce, sprinkled with fresh, shaved Parmesan cheese. Topped with our medley of croutons. Served with a side of Caesar dressing.
A blend of romaine and iceberg, tomato, onion, mushrooms, banana peppers, green peppers, olives, mozzarella and cheddar cheese. Served with your choice of dressing on the side.
A blend of romaine and iceberg lettuce topped with feta cheese, black olives, cucumber, roasted tomato, red onion and topped with Mediterranean dressing.
A blend of romaine and iceberg lettuce topped with cheddar cheese, mozzarella cheese, roasted tomato, red onion, corn and bean medley, cilantro and our Southwestern dressing.
• Add grilled chicken, BBQ chicken, fried chicken, turkey, tuna salad or pulled pork +$6.00
• Add turkey and bacon +$7.00
• Add grilled BBQ shrimp +$8.00
• Add grilled red fish +$10.00
• Add grilled salmon +$10.00
• Add bacon-wrapped scallops +$14.00
• Add grilled catch of the day MP
Powell's Tacos
For a gluten-free option, try it in our corn tortilla!
2 tacos with our skewered, grilled BBQ shrimp, topped with a lime cilantro slaw, tomato and our homemade chipotle crème in a flour tortilla. Served with a side of our homemade chips and famous salsa • Sub French Fries +$0.99 | Add Side Salad +$5.99
BBQ pulled pork in 2 flour tortillas, topped with cheddar cheese, lime cilantro slaw, tomatoes and chipotle crème. Served with a side of our homemade chips and famous salsa • Sub French Fries +$0.99 | Add Side Salad +$5.99
Delicious fried pollock in 2 flour tortillas, topped with a lime cilantro slaw, cheddar cheese, tomato and a chipotle crème. Served with chips and our homemade salsa on the side • Sub Grilled Red Fish +$1.00 | Sub French Fries +$0.99 | Add Side Salad +$5.99
2 flour tortillas with a generous portion of lightly-seared ahi tuna, topped with sesame seeds and lime cilantro slaw. Served with a side of our homemade chips and famous salsa • Sub French Fries +$0.99 | Add Side Salad +$5.99
Daisy's Delightful Wraps
All wraps served with chips, loaded potato salad or coleslaw. Sub French fries for an additional +$0.99 | Add side salad +$5.99 | Gluten-free wrap for an additional +$2.00 | Add a hot dog +$4.50
Marinated chicken breast grilled and blackened. Served with a creamy Caesar dressing topped with shaved Parmesan cheese.
Marinated chicken breast grilled and blackened. Served with lettuce, tomato and onion and a smoky BBQ sauce topped with cheddar • Add Bacon +$1.00
Juicy turkey breast, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, light mayo and provolone cheese.
Spicy black bean patty with cheddar cheese, chipotle crème, lettuce, tomato and onion.
Frosty's favorite fried chicken strips smothered in spicy buffalo sauce and topped with provolone cheese. Served in a flour tortilla with lettuce, tomato, onion and a side of ranch or blue cheese.
White albacore tuna salad with provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion, wrapped so tight it won't get away.
For our vegan friends, try our tortilla wrap with lettuce, tomato, onion, mushrooms, banana peppers, green peppers and olives. Served with a side of balsamic or fat-free Italian dressing • Add Cheese +$0.99
With lettuce, tomato and onion. Served with your choice of tartar or our red pepper sauce • Fried Fish $17.99 | Salmon $18.99 | Grilled Catch of the Day MP
Entrees
All sandwiches served with chips, loaded potato salad or coleslaw.
Substitute French fries for an additional $0.99 | Add side salad +$5.99 Add a hot dog +$4.50
Steamed snow crab legs served with warm butter and your choice of a side. 1 lb. or 2 lbs.
Fresh catch of the day lightly blackened and grilled. Served on a toasted bun with lettuce, tomato and onion with a slice of lemon and tartar sauce on the side.
Frosty's soon-to-be world-famous lump crab cake. Pan-seared and served on a toasted bun with lettuce, tomato, onion and a side of our house-roasted red pepper sauce.
Rusty's huge crusted cod fillet, deep fried til golden brown, served over fries or get this great catch on a toasted bun with cheddar, lettuce, tomato and onion.
If you thought groupers had no fingers, you're right. We couldn't think of a better name. Lightly-battered grouper served with French fries and homemade tartar sauce.
White albacore tuna salad served warm with melted provolone, toasted to perfection and topped with lettuce, tomato and onion.
Handcrafted 10 oz. monster! We patty only Black Angus beef and cook it to perfection. Served with lettuce, tomato, pickle and onion • Add Cheese +$0.99: American, Provolone, Swiss, Pepper Jack, Pimento, Cheddar, Mozzarella or Crumbled Blue Cheese | Add Bacon +$0.99 | Add Grilled Mushrooms or Onions +$0.99 | Add Grilled Mushrooms and Onions +$1.50
Grilled red fish lightly seasoned with Cajun, garlic and dill. Served on a bun with lettuce, tomato, onion, a slice of lemon and tartar sauce on the side.
Frosty packed this thing with a boat load of shrimp! You know our burger is the best around, so get your sea legs ready and give this one a go. Served on a toasted bun with lettuce, tomato, onion and a side of our house remoulade.
Thick, juicy chicken tenders (4) lightly breaded and served with French fries. Comes with your choice of dipping sauce • Try it Buffalo-style +$0.99 | Extra Dressing +$0.99
Grilled chicken breast perfectly seasoned our way, blackened and topped with provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion on a toasted bun • Get it with BBQ Sauce +$0.50 | Get it with Teriyaki and Pineapple +$1.00 | Get it Buffalo-style with Crumbled Blue Cheese +$1.50
The island's best BLT overflowing with bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo. Served on toasted bread.
BBQ pulled pork on a toasted bun with melted cheddar cheese. Served with our homemade slaw.
Hand-sliced, all-beef bologna cut thick, blackened and pan-sautéed, then piled high on toasted bread with American cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion.
Freshly-sliced smoked turkey piled high and toasted to perfection with applewood bacon, mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion and provolone cheese.
Our pulled pork and turkey piled on a toasted hoagie with melted Swiss and served with spicy mustard and pickles.
Thinly-sliced prime rib sautéed to perfection and topped with provolone cheese • Add Grilled Mushrooms and Onions +$1.50
Frosty's same great burger just 5 oz. and smashed on the griddle. Served on a toasted bun with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle and our house pub sauce • Add Cheese +$0.99: American, Provolone, Swiss, Pepper Jack, Pimento, Cheddar, Mozzarella or Crumbled Blue Cheese | Add Bacon +$0.99
Frosty's spicy black bean burger served on a toasted bun with lettuce, tomato and onion. Topped with our spicy house chipotle crème, and your choice of cheese.
Klahr's Tadpole Menu
All Tadpole meals served with chips, fries, loaded potato salad or coleslaw. Drink not included.
One cluster of steamed snow crab legs served with warm butter and your choice of side item.
6 breaded shrimp fried and served with your choice of side item.
¼ lb. all-beef dog. Your choice of side item • Add an Extra Dog +$4.50
A kid favorite served with your choice of a side item.
A kid-sized portion of chicken (2) and fries.
Try this favorite with American and cheddar cheeses toasted to perfection. Served with your choice of a side item.
Baked on pita bread with our sauce, cheese and pepperoni.
A side house or Caesar salad.
Sullivan's Desserts
The perfect sweet ending for any meal or just for fun in the middle of the day! Please ask your server for the current flavor selections (1 pop).
Bristol's Dog Menu
For dogs only please. No seasoning, no spices, no bread, no sides.